Buying Before Selling in Colorado Springs: 5 Options (2026)

by Crystal & Shawn -


Buying Before Selling in Colorado Springs (2026): How to Move Up Without Getting Stuck With Two Mortgages

Can you buy a new home in Colorado Springs before you sell the one you're in? Yes. Plenty of people do it. The real question is how you'll pay for it and how long you can comfortably carry two homes, because that is what decides which strategy fits you.

Buying before selling usually comes down to one of five paths: make your offer contingent on selling your current home, borrow against your current equity with a bridge loan or HELOC, qualify for both payments outright, keep your current home as a rental, or flip the order and sell first while renting back for a short time. Each one trades money, risk, and stress in a different way. Here's how they actually work, so you can pick on purpose instead of by panic.

The Short Answer: Which Order Makes Sense?

There's no universally right order. There's the order that matches your finances and your nerves.

  • Buy first if you have the equity or income to bridge the gap, you need certainty about where you're landing (a PCS date, a school calendar, a job start), or you'd rather not move twice.
  • Sell first if you need every dollar of your current equity for the down payment, you can't qualify with both payments on your debt, or the idea of carrying two mortgages makes you lose sleep.
  • Do both at once with tight timing and the right contract tools if you want the best of both and you have a team that can coordinate two closings.

One thing we tell our buyers: decide your plan before you fall in love with a house. Strategy made on a Tuesday at the kitchen table is a lot better than strategy made in a driveway after a showing.

Your Options at a Glance

Strategy

How it works

Biggest upside

Biggest catch

Home sale contingency

Your purchase depends on your current home selling

Limits the risk of owning two homes

Weaker offer; many sellers won't accept it

Bridge loan or HELOC

Borrow against current equity for the down payment

Lets you make a non-contingent offer

Extra cost, extra debt, and you still have to qualify

Carry both payments

Qualify for the new mortgage with the old one still on your debt

Simplest if your income supports it

Two payments until the old home sells

Keep it as a rental

Convert your current home to an investment property

Keeps the asset and any low existing rate

Landlord duties, reserves, and tax implications

Sell first, rent back

Sell, then stay for a short, agreed period after closing

Cash in hand and a strong buying position

Tight deadline to find and close on the next home

Option 1: Make Your Offer Contingent on Selling Your Home

A home sale contingency means your purchase only goes forward if your current home sells (or goes under contract and closes) by a date written into the contract. If it doesn't, you can typically walk away without losing your earnest money, depending on how the contingency is written.

It isn't automatic. It has to be negotiated and written into your offer, and the seller has to agree to it.

When a sale contingency works

  • Your current home is already listed, or better, already under contract.
  • The home you want has been on the market a while and the seller is motivated.
  • Your timeline is realistic and your home is priced to actually sell.

When it doesn't

  • Competitive listings with multiple offers. A contingent offer usually loses to a clean one.
  • Your home isn't listed yet. To a seller, that reads as "maybe someday."
  • Some new construction sales. Builder contracts are their own documents with their own rules, so ask the builder's sales team up front whether they'll consider a sale contingency at all.

If you go this route, make it as strong as possible: get your home listed (or under contract) first, show solid lender pre-approval, and keep the contingency deadline tight.

Option 2: Use Your Equity With a Bridge Loan or HELOC

If you've built up equity in your current home, you can borrow against it to fund the down payment on the next one, then pay that debt off when the old home sells.

  • Bridge loan: A short-term loan secured by your current home, designed to cover the gap between buying and selling. These tend to carry higher costs than a standard mortgage, and terms vary a lot by lender.
  • HELOC (home equity line of credit): A line of credit against your current home. Timing matters here: open it before you list, because lenders are generally reluctant to open a new line on a home that's already on the market.

The catch nobody puts on the brochure: borrowing against your equity doesn't erase your payments. You may be carrying your current mortgage, the equity loan, and the new mortgage at the same time until your old home closes. Your lender still has to qualify you with that debt included. Have that conversation with a licensed loan officer before you shop, not after.

Option 3: Qualify With Both Payments

If your income and debt-to-income ratio can support both housing payments at once, this is the cleanest path. You buy the new home, move at your own pace, then list the old one, often vacant, which makes prep and showings much easier.

The honest math check: how many months could you carry both payments, plus utilities, insurance, and HOA or metro district costs on two properties, without touching money you need for life? If the answer makes you wince, pick a different option or build a hard deadline for listing.

Option 4: Keep Your Current Home as a Rental

A lot of Colorado Springs homeowners are sitting on a mortgage rate they don't want to give up. Converting your current home into a long-term rental can let you keep that loan and the asset while you buy the next place.

If you're using a conventional loan, Fannie Mae's Selling Guide has specific rules for counting rent from a "departing residence." Per the Fannie Mae Selling Guide section on departing residences (updated September 2026), lenders generally use 75% of the documented market rent, subtract the full housing payment on that home, and count the result. Market rent can be supported by an appraisal with a rent schedule or by comparable rentals, and lease agreements alone aren't accepted for a departing residence. Borrowers with less than a year of property management experience may also need extra cash reserves.

Translation: you might not get full credit for that rent, and you'll need savings on top of your down payment. Your lender will apply the rules that fit your specific loan.

Before you become a landlord, also think through:

  • Your HOA covenants and any rental restrictions in your community.
  • Whether you'll self-manage or hire a property manager.
  • Insurance changes (a landlord policy is different from a homeowner's policy).
  • Taxes, especially the capital gains exclusion clock covered below.

Option 5: Sell First and Rent Back

Selling first puts you in the strongest buying position: your equity is in the bank and your offer can be non-contingent. The fear is being homeless between closings. A rent-back helps with that.

In Colorado, the Real Estate Commission publishes an optional Post-Closing Occupancy Agreement (the current version is for use on and after January 1, 2026). It lets the seller stay in the home for a defined period after closing, under terms both sides agree to, such as rent, deposit, utilities, and the condition the home must be in when you hand over the keys.

Things to know before counting on a rent-back:

  • The buyer has to agree, and their lender may limit how long a seller can stay after closing. Ask early.
  • You're now a tenant in a home you no longer own. Read the agreement carefully and talk with your own advisors about insurance during that window.
  • It buys you time, not a lot of time. Have your next home search well underway before you sell.

Military and VA Buyers: A Few Extra Wrinkles

For our military clients, buy-before-sell questions usually show up around a PCS. A few things worth knowing:

  • Keeping a VA loan on your current home. Depending on your remaining entitlement, you may be able to use a VA loan again while the first one stays in place. The rules are explained on the VA home loans page, and your lender can review your Certificate of Eligibility with you.
  • Occupancy. VA loans are for homes you intend to live in, so the new home needs to be your primary residence.
  • Renting the old home. Many service members keep a home as a rental after a move. The same landlord, insurance, and tax questions apply.

This is general real estate guidance, not official military or VA guidance. Your lender and your installation's housing office are the right sources for program-specific answers.

Don't Forget Taxes

If you sell your main home, the IRS lets you exclude up to 250,000ofgain(500,000 for most married couples filing jointly) if you owned and lived in it for at least two of the five years before the sale, according to IRS Topic No. 701, Sale of Your Home.

Why this matters for buying before selling: if you move out and rent the old home for a while, that five-year window keeps moving. Wait too long to sell and you could lose some or all of the exclusion. We're Realtors, not CPAs, so talk with a tax professional before you decide to rent instead of sell.

Selling the Old Home After You've Moved Out

Here's a quiet perk of buying first: a vacant home is way easier to prep, photograph, and show. No more making beds at 7 a.m. because a showing popped up. No more herding the dog into the car.

The downside is that empty rooms can look smaller and colder online. Because we also own a professional staging company, Everyday Staging, staging is included in our listing packages. When we're preparing one of our listings that's already vacant, staging is how we help buyers picture how the space actually lives instead of guessing.

A Simple Game Plan for Buying Before Selling

  1. Talk to a lender first. Find out whether you qualify with both payments, whether rental income would count, and what a bridge loan or HELOC would actually look like.
  2. Get a realistic value on your current home. Your equity drives almost every option on this list.
  3. Pick your strategy before you shop. Contingent, bridge, carry both, rent it out, or sell first.
  4. Open any HELOC before listing, if that's part of the plan.
  5. Prep the current home early. Repairs, decluttering, and staging plans can happen while you search.
  6. Line up both timelines. Your agent should be coordinating your listing date, your offer terms, and your closing dates as one plan.
  7. Build a backup. Know what you'll do if the old home takes longer to sell than expected: a price adjustment point, a rent-back, or short-term housing.

The Honest Risks

We'll be straight with you. Buying before selling can go sideways in a few predictable ways:

  • Your home sits longer than planned. Every extra month is another double payment.
  • Overpricing to protect the budget. Pricing your old home high because you "need" a number usually makes it sit. The market doesn't care what you need.
  • Thin cash reserves. A surprise repair on either house hits harder when you're carrying two.
  • Contract deadlines. Contingency dates, loan deadlines, and closing dates on two transactions have to line up. Missing one can cost real money.

None of these are reasons not to do it. They're reasons to plan it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I buy a house in Colorado Springs before selling my current one?

Yes, as long as you can qualify for the new loan with your current housing payment counted, or you use a tool like a bridge loan, HELOC, or rental income to make the numbers work. A lender can tell you which options you qualify for before you start touring.

Will a seller accept an offer contingent on selling my home?

Sometimes. Sellers are more open to it when your home is already listed or under contract, your pre-approval is solid, and their home has been on the market a while. In a multiple-offer situation, a contingent offer usually has a harder time competing.

Can I use rent from my current home to qualify for my next mortgage?

Often, yes, with limits. Under Fannie Mae's current guidelines for conventional loans, lenders generally count 75% of documented market rent against the payment on your departing home, and may require additional reserves. Your lender will apply the rules for your specific loan type.

What is a rent-back, and is it allowed in Colorado?

A rent-back lets you stay in the home you sold for a set period after closing. Colorado brokers commonly use the Real Estate Commission's optional Post-Closing Occupancy Agreement to put the terms in writing. The buyer and their lender both need to be on board.

Is it better to buy first or sell first?

It depends on your equity, income, and tolerance for risk. Buying first gives you certainty and one move; selling first gives you cash and a stronger offer. Many people end up doing both close together with carefully matched closing dates.

Do I lose my capital gains exclusion if I rent out my old home?

Not automatically, but you can if you wait too long to sell. The IRS exclusion generally requires that you owned and lived in the home for two of the five years before the sale, so a long rental period can affect it. A tax professional can look at your exact dates.

Ready to Map Out Your Move?

If you're trying to figure out whether to buy or sell first in Colorado Springs, Peyton, Falcon, Monument, or anywhere in the Pikes Peak region, we'd be happy to help you build the plan: what your current home could sell for, how to time your listing and your purchase, and which lender conversations to have first. Call or text Crystal Sisler and Shawn Bedel with Everyday Properties & Investments, powered by eXp Realty, at 719.238.1771.

Crystal & Shawn -
Crystal & Shawn -

Agent

+1(719) 238-1771 | team@everydaypropertiesandinvestments.com

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message